← InsightsChina / GBA
Sorry isn’t enough Guilt ends with a confession. Shame starts with one
David Thomas
I was 18, sitting in the car with my father one night in the late 70s. I’d just told him my final school exam results. He was a high achiever. Mine were very average.
He didn’t need to say much. I knew they were bad. I’d let myself down.
That part was guilt. A private conversation with my own conscience.
Then came the silence. The driving rain against the windscreen was the only sound. I tried to be cheerful and change the subject. Nothing was being said, and the discomfort was unbearable.
That part was shame.
Every culture has both, but across much of Asia shame tends to speak first. Shame is about everyone watching. Your family, your colleagues, the people who backed you.
In 2013, a contamination scare at Fonterra led China to restrict some New Zealand dairy imports. Prime Minister John Key promised to fly to Beijing himself and apologise for the whole nation. It was “important in their culture”, he said. The scare turned out to be a false alarm. He still went, to explain in person.
Earlier this month Jensen Huang, the co-founder and chief executive of Nvidia, wrote to his staff admitting he had been unfaithful to his wife. “There is no excuse for what I did.” A textbook confession. The wider story is still unfolding.
A Chinese friend used to put it simply. “It’s one thing to make a mistake or do something wrong, but what’s more important is what you do about it.”
Jensen Huang's letter also promises to work to earn back his staff’s confidence. That’s the part people will be watching.
It’s probably what my father was wondering in that car. What would I do next?
With his backing, I took a year off, travelled the world and started work in the City of London instead of going to university. That made up for the results.
For anyone doing business in Asia, sorry is only where it starts.
PS. If you haven't already, please subscribe to Ground Level: Vietnam, a story from the street every two weeks, and why it matters. The second issue will be out tomorrow. It’s a separate list, so you’ll only get it if you sign up here.
More from the North-South Corridor at www.davidthomas.asia